Bare-bones budget: Council contingency, nonprofit grants, homeless programs, transfer stations, fireworks hit by cuts

  • Mayor Harry Kim

HILO — Hawaii County’s budget will break a half-billion dollars for the first time, but what’s not in the preliminary spending plan released Thursday is almost as significant as what’s in it.

Mayor Harry Kim’s $515.7 million draft budget is $24.9 million more than this year’s budget, a 5.1 percent increase. There are no tax increases in the preliminary plan, other than the fuel tax hike previously approved by the County Council.


Kim’s priorities, based on input from constituents, are homelessness, the transit system and parks maintenance. But even those weren’t spared in a budget that had no room for new programs.

In fact, most departments took reductions to what they presented as status quo spending.

“The budget we are sending is balanced, and we cut all the things we could cut,” Kim said.

Council Chairwoman Valerie Poindexter wasn’t pleased with the plan. She said she’s meeting Monday with House leadership to see how the state can help.

“I will be reviewing the budget that was submitted to us with a fine-tooth comb,” Poindexter said. “Are cuts being made in the appropriate areas? How many new hires and contracts were awarded during the last year? I have a call in to HR to get me some data.”

Most of the new spending is outside county control.

Employee salaries and fringe benefits, negotiated largely at the state level, will add $12.7 million. Included in that figure are contributions to the employee pension plan, at $4.4 million, and other post-retirement benefits for $5.9 million. Salaries recently awarded to top officials by the Salary Commission account for about $1.5 million more.

Principal and interest on money previously borrowed will cost $49 million.

Purchase and maintenance of land for preservation, public access and open space, as set in the county charter, will take $6.3 million.

There is no funding in the budget for homeless projects in East and West Hawaii, planned Hele-on bus improvements or fireworks displays. Transfer stations will now be closed on holidays.

Large road projects such as Ane Keohokalole extension to Kaiminani Drive are postponed. The county goal is to repave each mile of road once every 30 years, but the current rate budgeted is once every 69 years.

Council contingency funds are eliminated, saving $675,000. Another $255,000 is cut from tourism promotion and the usual $1.5 million for nonprofit grants is cut back to the legally required $1 million.

On the revenue side, an additional $12.4 million is expected to be picked up in property taxes because of increased valuations and construction activity. Another $8.8 million extra is expected to come from fuel taxes, with about $3.5 million coming from this year’s rate increase.

Grants will bring in an additional $7.7 million, with $3.5 million coming from a federal Housing Choice Voucher Program grant.

After releasing the budget Thursday, Kim was still lobbying for a half-cent local surcharge to the general excise tax, which would bring at least $25 million annually to the budget. A measure to add the new tax remains stalled in the council.

“In order to balance the budget, many items were removed from the budget,” Kim said in his budget message. “The budget is balanced based on estimated revenues, but that does not mean it is a realistic budget. The budget should contain what is needed to help the people of our county and provide necessary services.”

Poindexter didn’t like seeing the GET surcharge as a bargaining chip.

“I am very concerned about the administration asking us to raise the general excise tax immediately after asking us to approve raising property taxes and the gas taxes — then to see such exorbitant raises get awarded is like rubbing salt into a wound,” Poindexter said. “Further tax increases are going to be a real challenge. People in my district are very upset.”

Finance Committee Chairwoman Maile David had a similar reaction.

“Services and funding cuts are drastic,” David said. “However, I look forward to working together with my colleagues in finding solutions to our budget situation without imposing further tax burdens on our citizens.”

The preliminary proposed budget now goes to the County Council, which will hold departmental reviews April 17-19.

The mayor’s final proposed budget will be released by May 5. Once amended and passed by the council, it goes into effect July 1.

  1. LOL in Kona March 2, 2018 5:35 am

    Haaa, Haaa, Haaa!
    They take in $28,000,000 extra this year
    …but they are “broke”!
    …..cuz then must, must, must spend more, more, more – $515,700,000!

    it is soooo rough, they have to have a raise!!
    ….how’s your water doing? changed rules on septic?
    Haaa, Haaa, Haaa,
    ….and they will sell us the bridge from Hawi to Hana!!
    …..and we’ll buy it cuz we are so gull-i-bull!!
    Of course, the police, fire, medical are “extra” and *may* be laid off!!
    ….but the new! improved! housing for leeches, loafers, druggies is great!
    Haaa, Haaa, Haaa!

  2. Buds4All March 2, 2018 7:24 am

    “Another $255,000 is cut from tourism promotion” you would think the state would bring all the major players from resorts, restaurants and attractions together and find a way for these business to promote HI since it benefits them most of all?

    1. KonaDude March 2, 2018 9:07 am

      I’m with you on the train thing!! But who hasn’t heard of Hawaii? How much promoting is needed? With all the bad press Mexico vacations have been getting that’s got to be helping the Hawaii tourism business?? Maybe I just don’t understand what they spend that money on I guess..
      If taxes are rubbing you the wrong way maybe you should think about who we vote into office. this isn’t directed at you Buds4All, I’m just ranting.

      1. Buds4All March 2, 2018 9:33 am

        KDude….trips for them and their families to the 9th Island to Promote a place where everyone wants to visit anyway!

  3. Buds4All March 2, 2018 7:24 am

    Oh and lets not forget about that stupid train!

  4. KonaLife March 2, 2018 7:40 am

    I think the politicians believe the general population is clamoring for new and expand services. Some special interests with savvy lobbying efforts are, but at the end of the day, I believe the average person would prefer a little less from the government and a little more of the money they earn in their pocket. Simply put: if I could pay less in taxes (GE, vehicle registration fees, gas taxes, property taxes, income taxes, use fees, etc.) and have that money for my family I would. I believe most people would. So, a “bare-bones” budget is good and increasing the GE tax, bad.

  5. Mauka Tom March 2, 2018 8:08 am

    Glad they got rid of the Council contingency slush fund at least.

  6. Sonny Poindexter March 2, 2018 8:13 am

    Transfer stations are already closed on holidays ! Hello !

    1. KonaRich March 2, 2018 8:53 am

      It might have been put in the budget to open the stations on holidays for so many dollars, then cut and thus it falls in the cut side. For sake of discussion, lets say each department spent 1M last year and this year sends in a budget of 1.4M then the finance committee says no you can only have 1.1M thus a .3M cut (to brag about). And it keep rising.

  7. Servite Omak March 2, 2018 8:37 am

    wasting hard earned tax payers money as usual, and what they had last year is never enough, ever!

  8. Aaron Stene March 2, 2018 11:01 am

    Ane K. Highway Phase III won’t be postponed. The mayor’s budget message doesn’t state this. It states there isn’t enough fuel tax revenue to do big ticket highway projects at this time. I spoke to DPW also, and confirmed the preliminary engineering and environmental assessment will continue for this project.

  9. 4whatitsworth March 2, 2018 11:41 am

    In an up economy current taxes revenues should be going up because property values go up, spending goes up, wages go up, and gas usage goes up, all these items are taxed significantly. These clowns will never have enough of other peoples money don’t fall for the B.S.!

  10. Michael M March 2, 2018 2:41 pm

    How about cutting out the Huge raises they gave themselves for a start.

  11. jim williams March 2, 2018 4:27 pm

    Da Hui is ruling this Island and must be voted out! Bare bones budget my arse.

    1. Scooby March 3, 2018 10:38 am

      Lie tax spend and do it again Kim.

  12. Big ideas March 3, 2018 2:59 pm

    Kill the County band and move the money to replace-repair west side wells…..there is a priority you can push

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email