Ranchers in a bind after Hilo butcher shop suspends small animal operations

  • Kulana Foods is located off of Kawailani Street in Hilo. (Hollyn Johnson/Tribune-Herald)

HILO — A second animal handling violation for one of the only slaughterhouses on the Big Island has some ranchers worried about their futures.

Hilo butcher shop Kulana Foods was briefly suspended from operations in December after an inspector with the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service reported employees mishandled a pig during transportation.


According to the USDA report, the employees were attempting to unload an uncooperative pig from a truck. After the pig refused to stand, the employees reportedly attempted to drag the animal from the truck using ropes tied to its ankles.

The inspector informed the employees they were not allowed to drag a conscious pig, whereupon the employees lifted the pig and carried it from the truck. After removing the pig from the truck, the animal willingly stood and was led away without further incident.

Kulana’s suspension was issued on Dec. 27, but it was held in abeyance the following day after Kulana Foods proposed corrective actions to prevent further incidents.

However, despite being permitted to continue slaughter operations, Kulana Foods informed island ranchers that it would be ceasing small animal slaughter operations indefinitely.

“I guess they decided it’s too risky to keep the small animal slaughter up,” said Brittany Anderson, owner of Sugar Hill Farmstead in Honomu.

Anderson speculated that Kulana Foods feared that repeated suspensions for its small animal operations — which include pigs, lambs and sheep — would threaten its much larger cattle slaughter market.

“They called us and explained the incident and told us they would temporarily be stopping services,” said Leslie Carroll, owner of the Carroll Guava Ranch in Keaau, which raises lambs that would ordinarily be slaughtered at Kulana Foods.

Carroll said she suspects the citations against Kulana Foods are the result of politically motivated individuals who are opposed to the consumption of animals. In fact, Kulana’s first citation led to animal rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals calling for a criminal investigation against the company.

With Kulana Foods halting small animal slaughters, Carroll said she has no option to have her lambs slaughtered on the island.

Because Carroll sells lamb meat at local markets, the slaughter process has to be USDA approved, she said. While Carroll said she is more than capable of humanely slaughtering lambs herself, without USDA approval, the meat cannot legally be sold.

While a mobile slaughterhouse operated by the Hawaii Island Meat Cooperative is periodically available, Carroll said she would have to slaughter about half of her flock for that option to be financially viable.

Without available slaughter options, ranchers are being forced to make hard decisions about what to do with their livestock. Anderson said she knows of one pig farmer who has sold off most of his animals at a loss, while her own herd of 14 sheep is running out of space as new lambs are being born.

“We’ve just been slaughtering some of them ourselves and putting them in the freezer, and I guess we’ll be eating lamb for the next few months,” Carroll said, whose situation is similar to Anderson’s.

Carroll said if she cannot find a place to slaughter her lambs soon, she might have to stop raising the animals altogether.

“It’s taken me years to get here, to get all the knowledge and skill to make this work, and it will all go away,” Carroll said.


Representatives of Kulana Foods did not respond to numerous requests for comment.

Email Michael Bretovansky at mbrestovansky@hawaiitribune-herald.com.

  1. Jose Martinez January 30, 2019 5:56 am

    one more small company bites the dust.maybe they should stop all fishermen,as the fish get caught on a “painful”hook.

  2. Scooby January 30, 2019 6:52 am

    Dragging a pig is in humane? The pig will be pork chops and pork butt!

  3. Sweet Leilani January 30, 2019 11:07 am

    HM… I still think that theres alot moreto this story that is not being told…

  4. Brdy P. January 30, 2019 9:19 pm

    The writer needs to dig a bit deeper for this article, because the details about how “uncooperative” the pig in question was are critical for determining whether dragging or otherwise coaxing the animal was properly performed. The humane slaughter of livestock regulations (9 CFR 313) section 313.2(d)(2) specifies that, “the dragging of disabled animals and other animals unable to move,
    while conscious, is prohibited.” The article states that the pig, after being carried, was able to stand and walk away on its own. This suggests that the pig was not “disabled” or “unable to move.” Rather, the pig was unwilling to move. Section 313.2 paragraphs (a) through (c) specify the methods allowed for coaxing animals to move. Such methods include electric prods and other methods. It seems to me that dragging may be more humane than other allowed methods, so the inspector’s call on the incident might be off the mark. I’m not saying that it is, but I do believe that the reporter has the opportunity–if not the duty–to investigate the situation to shed light on how the inspection process is working here on the Big Island.

    1. LimeyinHi January 30, 2019 10:15 pm

      Don’t hurt the pig, you might kill it!

  5. Niel Thomas February 1, 2019 7:16 am

    The Waimea Butcher Shop has a sign in the store about this decision by the slaughterhouse, saying pork, lamb and sheep products won’t be available indefinitely. I was told there was to be a meeting Wednesday, the day this piece appeared. This is certainly going to be a hardship on farmers, retailers and consumers. A new startup would require millions of dollars investment, and isn’t likely to happen as long as Kulana Foods has the capability of production, if not the willingness.

  6. Dave Thompson February 3, 2019 8:30 am

    Can individual people slaughter their own animals and bring them in to be processed, or will they not process small animals either?

  7. Bond February 3, 2019 5:02 pm

    PEOPLE EAT TASTY ANIMALS PETA what do you do with a uncooperative pig kill it its made to consume some of these idiots the hdoh hire what ya gonna do talk it to death

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email hawaiiwarriorworld@staradvertiser.com.