Creativity abounds at our Legislature

This year, our Legislature once again is poised to consider revenue raising – namely, taxes in new and creative ways. For a different perspective on the issue, we’re asking the Hawaii State Tax Watch Doggie, who has been going through the hundreds of introduced bills.

Q: So do you see any new and unusual revenue raisers there?


A: Woof! Arf! Yap!

Q: Use the keyboard.

A: SB 395 would charge conveyance taxes on leases shorter than five years.

Q: Conveyance tax, the tax paid on real estate sales? But if the real estate is being rented, what’s the tax going to be paid on?

A: It’s on the present value of the lease payment stream.

Q: That couldn’t be much. What would be the tax on a one-year lease where the rent is $1,000 a month?

A: $17.43.

Q: Maybe you can get one bag of dog food for that.

A: Then there’s HB 646, which would charge a certain dollar amount per person per day on a business providing live adult entertainment.

Q: How much is the tax?

A: The amount is blank now.

Q: How are they going to enforce it? Will they need to send people to the establishment to count the patrons?

A: I’ll volunteer! I, um, am curious about what kind of people go there.

Q: Not sure that’ll work. You need to be 18 years old to go in, and you’re only 7.

A: Bummer.

Well then, there’s HB 231, which is entitled “Tax Fairness.”

Q: That’s scary.

A: It increases various credits given to low-income taxpayers and pays for them by raising income tax rates. The top tax rate would become 13 percent.

Q: Didn’t the income tax rates just go up?

A: Yes, they went up to 11 percent last year because of a bill passed in 2017. Guess they’re itching to be top dog in state tax rates!

Here’s another one. SB 112 wants the counties to authorize construction of new housing units. It specifies new housing unit targets for each county.

Q: And what happens if a county misses its target?

A: Then its share of transient accommodation tax money is reduced by $1.03 million.

Q: Ouch!

A: But it can get the money back if it makes its goal the following fiscal year!

And then, there’s SB 382. It would raise the transient accommodations tax on time share units.

Q: By how much would the tax go up?

A: I don’t know. The amount is blank now.

Q: So how do you know that the tax is going to be increased?

A: Because the first part of the bill says, “the existing tax formula for time shares significantly underestimates the fair market value … and therefore often fails to assess taxes at a fair and proper rate.”

Q: Oh.


A: Wish us luck following the Legislature this year! Woof!

Tom Yamachika is the president of the Tax Foundation of Hawaii.

  1. 4whatitsworth February 9, 2019 10:21 am

    More reasons for people who want to work and have opportunity to leave the state.

    In addition at some point the TAT is going to hit tourism and people are going to say wow between rental car and hotel tax I should go somewhere else and stay a few extra days.

    The silver lining is that it will pay even more to work for the government and the current regime will stay in power with all poor uneducated people that will collect here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email