CARES money uncertain: State budget woes may eat into neighbor island money

  • KIM

As the state struggles to resurrect an economy sucker-punched by the coronavirus, there were no guarantees Thursday that the neighbor islands will see their fair share of a federal bailout of local governments.

The state is trying to patch a $1.5 billion hole in its budget and there have been calls to use the federal money at the state level, rather than distribute it to neighbor island counties, which must rely on the governor’s discretion to get access to the federal funding.


“Hawaii’s economy is at a complete standstill,” Gov. David Ige said at a Thursday afternoon press conference. “One point five billion is a lot to make up.”

Hawaii is receiving $1.25 billion from the Coronavirus Relief Fund, of which $387.2 million goes directly to the City and County of Honolulu, the only local government with a population higher than 500,000. The $862.8 million remainder will be sent to the state, which has discretion over how to distribute it.

When asked directly how much of the $862.8 million will go to the neighbor islands and how much the state plans to keep, Ige remained unclear.

“We are in conversations with all of the counties, we continue to work with our congressional delegation,” Ige said in response to West Hawaii Today’s question. “Then we will begin to support the neighbor island counties as they fight COVID.”

With Ige contemplating pay cuts as much as 20% for state workers as one way to help balance the state budget, the Hawaii State Teachers Association said Wednesday it was looking into whether the state could use that money instead. U.S. Rep. Ed Case, a Democrat representing urban Honolulu, seemed to agree in a KHON2 article published Wednesday.

“There are some limitations to be using it but if the available state revenues are utilized for those purposes that might free up some space for him (Ige) to come in and allocate some money and maintain some of the state payrolls,” Case said in the article.

Case’s staff clarified that response Thursday. The congressman does not believe that Honolulu should give up its direct allocation, said spokesman Nestor Garcia. Future emergency assistance should go directly to counties and states, he said.

“There is some flexibility in how those limitations are applied, and we are all awaiting more specific guidance from the federal Treasury Department to clarify the range of uses. Even with those limitations there are whole ranges of use of those funds which look to be clearly authorized,” Case said through his spokesman. “These might include National Guard mobilization expenses not reimbursed to the State from other funding sources, to assisting with specific needs of the other counties that are not receiving a direct distribution, to supplementing overstretched social safety net programs.”

Sen. Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, in an April 8 meeting with the Hawaii County Council, assured the county money would be distributed to the neighbor islands.

“The counties’ pro-rata share will land in the state coffers,” Schatz said. “I can assure you the governor and the mayors are working together. … Because we’re working well together, your people will see their equitable share.”

A call and email to his office did not provide a direct answer by press-time Thursday.

The current money can be used only for necessary expenditures incurred because of the coronavirus public health emergency that were not accounted for in the most recently approved budget as of March 27 and were incurred between March 1 and Dec. 30, according to Treasury Department guidance issued earlier this week. The money is supposed to flow to states and local governments by April 24, a National Association of Counties spokesman said Thursday.

Hawaii County Mayor Harry Kim said Ige held a videoconference earlier Thursday with the county mayors to talk about the funding for local governments. Kim said he was disappointed about the restrictions on the money, but he seemed confident Hawaii County will get some of it. He said Ige will be forwarding more guidance on how the money can be spent.

“We spent a lot of money that we didn’t have. We went heavy on prevention and information,” Kim said. “Yes, the money will be helpful regardless.”


The National Association of Counties, the National League of Cities and the United States Conference of Mayors want more money sent to local governments and they want it to flow directly to them. The three local government groups sent a joint letter Thursday to President Trump and congressional leaders asking that an additional $250 billion in “robust, dedicated, and flexible funding” for cities and counties of all sizes be included in the next federal emergency funding package.

“All local governments, regardless of population, urgently need direct federal funding to help us continue to fight COVID-19 and protect our residents through the summer and beyond,” the letter said. “This will allow America’s hardest hit communities to deal with the enormous challenges we are facing while fairly distributing relief to all local governments.”

  1. irloyal April 17, 2020 1:20 am

    The delayed and inept handling of the State Finances is almost criminal. For the sake of Hawaii in the future, do not re-elect these power hungry politicians Your well being is placed in jeopardy by the continued slow and poor decision making of Ige, Shatz,Mazzie and others.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email