A 28-year old Kailua-Kona man will stand trial on a manslaughter charge stemming from an assault Dec. 3 that left a 64-year-old Holualoa man dead.
Daniel Watai-Simeona is accused of assaulting Menry Mendoza, who succumbed to his injuries Dec. 12. Watai-Simeona appeared Tuesday in Kona District Court for a preliminary hearing on the single charge.
Mendoza’s son took the stand and testified that on Dec. 3 he was preparing the yard for the upcoming storm at the Holualoa home he shared with his father. While securing items, he tied his dog to the trailer hitch of a truck, a 2018 Toyota Tacoma, and went to sleep.
Mendoza, not knowing the dog was tied to the truck, later left in the vehicle to drive to his workplace on Henry Street.
As Mendoza was driving, a family of three driving home to Hilo after attending the BIIF football championship game between Konawaena and Hilo high schools saw the truck while they were headed to grab a bite to eat at the Jack in the Box on Henry Street.
The driver of the vehicle carrying the family said they spotted the victim’s truck dragging something from behind and tried to get him to stop. They passed the victim on the right and got in front of the vehicle to make him stop.
The driver of the vehicle that tried to stop Mendoza said when Mendoza exited his truck, he was in shock when he realized what happened.
“Then brother man came out from nowhere yelling at the guy,” said the driver of the other vehicle of Watai-Simeona. “All I heard was a crack. I turned around and saw the man (Mendoza) fall backwards and hit his head on the pavement.”
The witness’s son testified he saw the defendant throw a punch at the victim, hitting him in the jaw and sending him to the ground.
The witnesses called 911 and stayed with the victim. They testified Watai-Simeona fled the scene when police arrived.
Hawaii Police Department Detective Tyler Prokopec testified EMS informed him that when they were trying to figure out what happened at the scene, a “homeless man,” later identified as Watai-Simeona, told them that he had punched the victim.
The victim’s son said he received a call from medics informing him that his father was in an accident and they were transporting him to Kona Community Hospital. When the son saw his father at the hospital, he said he was bloodied, bruised and incoherent.
“He was able to speak but not carry on a normal conversation,” he said.
The son was informed his father had to be flown to The Queen’s Medical Center in Honolulu where he was put into a medically induced coma to try to relieve the swelling in his brain. After a few days of observation, the son was told his father was brain dead.
Mendoza was taken off life support and died nine days after the incident.
An autopsy was performed on the victim with the cause of death listed as blunt force trauma to the head.
The victim’s son indicated his dog survived the accident and is undergoing treatment.
Kona District Court Judge Kimberly Taniyama determined there was enough evidence presented to send the case to Circuit Court for further proceedings.
Watai-Simeona will appear in front of Judge Robert D.S. Kim on Dec. 30 for his arraignment and Plea. He is being held at Hawaii Community Correctional Center on $250,000 bail.
