KEALAKEKUA— The struggle between access and exclusivity at the Four Seasons Hualalai passed a major initial step.
The plaintiffs, who seek to have reduced fees for unaccompanied guests at their properties and other lowered costs, will now be able to progress as a class action suit, 3rd Circuit Judge Melvin Fujino ruled Thursday.
A class action lawsuit allows a group of people in similar situations to have their case heard together, rather than individually.
Opposition attorneys argued that it was inappropriate, in part due to the comparative scarcity of other owners who agree with the plaintiff’s position.
“They cannot adequately protect the interests of the people in the Hualalai Clubs,” said William K. Meheula III, who is representing the Four Seasons.
The case, brought by property owner Christopher Zyda, challenges recent price increases for people who are at the club and wish to use the Four Seasons hotel amenities. He argues that is a violation of their contract, where the Four Seasons and other property owners argue he is trying to use his home as a money-making opportunity.
Meheula said a survey performed by an outside organization showed that the vast majority wanted exclusivity over greater use.
“Many of the club members want exclusivity to preserve the private club nature,” he said.