A bigger piece of the TAT pie

  • A panel of county department heads field questions at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha’s Kona Beach Hotel.

  • A panel of county department heads including Deputy Police Chief Kenneth Bugado, left, Mass Transit Administrator Maria “Sole” Aranguiz, Acting Public Works Director Allan Simeon, Finance Director Deanna Sako, DWS Manager-Chief Engineer Keith Okamoto, and Director of Parks and Recreation Roxcie Waltjen field questions at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha’s Kona Beach Hotel. (Laura Ruminski/West Hawaii Today)

  • A panel of county department heads field questions from a packed house at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha’s Kona Beach Hotel.

  • Deputy Police Chief Kenneth Bugado fills in for Chief Paul Ferreira at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha’s Kona Beach Hotel. (Photos by Laura Ruminski/West Hawaii Today)

  • Hawaii County Managing Director Will Okabe fills in for Mayor Harry Kim, the slated keynote speaker at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha's Kona Beach Hotel. (Laura Ruminski/West Hawaii Today)
  • Hawaii County Managing Director Wil Okabe fills in for Mayor Harry Kim, the slated keynote speaker at the Kona Kohala Chamber of Commerce Focus Luncheon Thursday at King Kamehameha’s Kona Beach Hotel. (Laura Ruminski/West Hawaii Today)

KAILUA-KONA — Hawaii Island Mayor Harry Kim was taken aback after he received a call Tuesday night from House Speaker Scott Saiki asking him to testify on a measure to increase Hawaii County’s share of the Transient Accommodations Tax by more than $12 million annually for at least the next dozen years.

Kim was even more pleasantly surprised Thursday when the legislation, Senate Bill 648, sailed through the House Committee on Finance, passing unanimously with amendments.


“To tell you the truth, this was so quiet that Tuesday was the first I’d heard of it,” the mayor said. “I really believed they’d shut the door on us last year because they said a $103 million maximum (to split among neighbor islands) in perpetuity.”

“That’s like saying ‘don’t bother us,’” Kim continued. “Obviously, I was wrong.”

The bill would increase Hawaii Island’s share of TAT revenues from $19.1 million to $31.2 million annually. It would also bump Kauai’s portion up nearly $9.5 million yearly and increase Maui’s share by a shade less than $15 million. The amount afforded to the city and county of Honolulu would remain unchanged.

Hawaii County’s financial situation was already stressed when Kim assumed office a little more than one year ago and the proposed budget for the upcoming fiscal year is expected to increase by around $25 million over the last, cracking the half-billion mark for the first time in history.

Collective bargaining increasing salaries and benefits for public employees, which occurred primarily at the state level, bumped this year’s budget up nearly $13 million. The Salary Commission also doled out several raises to high-ranking county officials, adding another $1.5 million.

In response, Hawaii County hiked both property and fuel taxes last year. Kim said the notion was as disconcerting as it was necessary, as property taxes now account for 72 percent of county revenue.

Kim sent over a revised budget to the County Council earlier this week full of deep cuts to homeless initiatives and other social programs, as well as several other projects.

“They were dramatic — and I mean dramatic — cuts,” Kim said.

An extra $12 million yearly would go a long way toward bolstering the Village 9 homeless project in Kailua-Kona and its companion project in Hilo, Kim said.

It will also potentially save smaller initiatives, like a program to help spay and neuter the county’s growing feral cat population and keep alive a joint county/state effort to combat destruction wrought by invasive albizia trees.

“Obviously, it’s a tremendous, tremendous boost as far as our budgetary problems,” Kim said.

Rep. Nicole Lowen (D-North Kona) sits on the Finance Committee and said she expects the bill to receive widespread support, even from Oahu representatives, when it heads to the House floor for a vote.

As to why the Legislature became suddenly amenable to the idea of granting a greater share of the TAT to neighbor islands, gifting around $36 million annually out of the state budget, Lowen explained much of it had to do with the special session in 2017.

During that session, legislators raised the TAT by 1 percent statewide to pay for Oahu’s ailing rail project — a move widely perceived as Oahu-based lawmakers strong-arming their neighbor island counterparts into bailing out the over-budget project.

“I think a lot of us neighbor island representatives were frustrated with how things went down during special session, and there wasn’t a lot of time to discuss things,” Lowen said. “There were a lot of issues that arose that we didn’t have time to deal with.”

“This, I think, rectifies that a little bit,” she added.

Also helpful was that SB 648 didn’t increase the share of the TAT heading to the city and county of Honolulu, which keeps the price tag on the move considerably lower.

Lowen guessed that a recent economic forecast from the Council on Revenues estimating an improved financial situation in Hawaii may have influenced lawmakers as well, leaving them more open to sharing the TAT wealth with counties.

“We’re all serving the same people and there’s a growth in tourism on neighbor islands … and a lot that has to be paid for,” Lowen said. “Hopefully this can be the start of a bigger conversation looking at all our sources of revenue and the tax system and figuring out where revenue can be generated in a way that’s going to be least harmful to local residents that can least afford it.”

The general excise tax is widely considered one of the most, if not the most, regressive tax in Hawaii, disproportionately impacting its lowest-income residents. Kim has proposed an increase to Hawaii County’s GET of 0.5 percent, which is currently being considered by the County Council.

Kim said he will not rescind the proposal because, as Hawaii County Managing Director Wil Okabe explained, the TAT measure “is not a done deal,” and the time limit on bumping the GET may expire before a TAT increase would be made official.

The state afforded counties the option to raise the GET during the same special session in which legislators raised the TAT.

GET revenues are only available for operating or capital costs for public transportation, meaning the roughly $25 million the 0.5 percent bump would generate annually could be used for highway projects or to aid the county’s beleaguered mass transit system.

“I’ll keep pushing that,” Kim said. “I know it’s a difficult hill to climb, but I feel it’s that important.”

TAT revenues are not subject to such stringent restrictions as those from the GET and can be used to fund any project under the county’s general plan, development plan or tourism strategic plan.

The GET hike would sunset in 2030, the same year as the TAT. Both would likely merit discussion for continuation, as is common with laws that generate substantial revenues but are subject to expiration dates.

In the meantime, a GET increase in Hawaii County could bolster initiatives rendered considerably more viable if the TAT increase makes its way through the Legislature.


SB 648 will have to pass second and third readings in the House before heading back to the Senate. Lowen said if the Senate moves the bill through without adding amendments, it would head directly to the governor for his signature.

If amendments are added, the bill would head to conference committee and a draft would be produced for consideration in both chambers. If such a draft passed, gaining Ige’s signature would be the final step for the TAT reform to become law.

  1. jim williams March 16, 2018 2:16 am

    Salary Commission , that’s a good one! An unelected governmental body tasked with giving raises to our deserving public servants. No issues there. As to the additional funds coming to Hawaii County, pay down our debt please.

  2. Big ideas March 16, 2018 6:16 am

    Hawaii County hiked both property and fuel taxes last year.

    OK so instead of going on a spending spree…KEEP the budget reductions and roll back as much of the taxes as possible…starting with the regressive gas tax! It hits low income earners VERY HARD!

    1. diverdave March 17, 2018 9:24 am

      Right, and they should NOT allow a raise in the G.E.T. now either.

  3. 4whatitsworth March 16, 2018 7:49 am

    “It should also be noted that the counties have the authority to raise local revenues and issue their own bonds should they need additional funding for capital projects,” – Said Laurel Johnston, director of the state Department of Budget and Finance (In another article)

    No Ms Johnson “It should be said that the rail project is a catastrophic mistake second only to the awful collective barging of the state at tax payers expense”. Please fix this!

  4. Bill Bugbee March 16, 2018 9:41 am

    Kim and other island governors, like the state, must operate within a balanced budget, unlike the deficit-driven Federal government.

    DBEDT reported Hawaii’s state government share of combined state and local government expenditures is 79.8 percent, proportionally, the highest spending state in the nation.
    Hawaii’s sales tax (GET), a tax on everything (including medicine and food) ranks the 3rd highest state in the nation. Hawai’i Island’s primary revenue source is the TAT visitor tax, followed by GET, both almost entirely sucked up by Oahu.

    Hawai’i Island has also seen its fair share of infrastructure stresses from recent spikes in population and visitor growth: more tourists, more direct flights, greater seating capacity.

    Long overdue, will be if the state legislature can achieve a fair-share split revenue between the outer islands and Oahu. Mayor Kim and Hawai’i Island’s state representatives and senators have historically pleaded that are helpless to reform the TAT in the face of Oahu’s political majority and spending priorities – we’ll see…

    1. diverdave March 17, 2018 9:25 am

      Wait a minute Bill, the so called “balanced budget” includes more bonds, which increases the debt.

      1. Bill Bugbee March 17, 2018 11:08 am

        All true.

  5. klay March 17, 2018 2:57 pm

    Don’t think that us mainlanders don’t see these rising TAT taxes as well, it’s a real shock to see the final bill after your stay. Makes you think twice about coming back

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email hawaiiwarriorworld@staradvertiser.com.