Honokaa woman arrested for murder of toddler who died in foster care

  • Fabian Garett-Garcia, 3, died July 25, 2017, at North Hawaii Community Hospital in Waimea after police and medics responded to a foster home in Waimea where the child was found not breathing. (Courtesy photo/Special to West Hawaii Today)

  • Chasity Alcosiba, 44, was arrested Wednesday afternoon on suspicion of second-degree murder. After her arrest, police contacted the Prosecutor’s Office, which declined to press charges against Alcosiba at the time. She was then released from custody. (HPD/Special to West Hawaii Today)
  • During a March 23 sign-waving event in Waimea, Kawika Spencer Oliveira, left, and Keziah Grant Spencer hold signs in support of justice for Fabian Garett-Garcia. (Laura Ruminski/West Hawaii Today)

KAILUA-KONA — The parents of a 3-year-old toddler who died last year while in foster care are hopeful a 44-year-old Honokaa woman arrested for murder in connection with the boy’s death will be brought to justice.

“Today, our suspicions and worst fears were confirmed when we were told that our 3-year-old son Fabian Garett-Garcia was murdered,” Fabian’s parents, Sherri-Ann Garett and Juben Garcia, said in a statement via their attorney Jeffrey Foster. “There are no words that can describe the way we feel today.


“We would like to send our heartfelt thanks and aloha to Detective Carrie Akina and the Hawaii County Police Department for their hard work and dedication in bringing Fabian’s killer to justice,” the statement continued. “We would also like to thank our ohana, friends and community who have offered prayers, love and support during the most difficult time of our lives. Mahalo.”

Hawaii Police officers took 44-year-old Chasity Alcosiba into custody shortly before 3 p.m. Wednesday at a home off Kahana Drive in Hamakua, on a warrant for arrest for second-degree murder.

After her arrest, police contacted the Prosecutor’s Office, which declined to press charges against Alcosiba at the time. She was then released from custody.

Reached Thursday, Hawaii County Prosecutor Mitch Roth acknowledged his office has the case and said it was under investigation.

“We have deputies (prosecutors) who are now looking into it,” said Roth, who declined further comment due to the ongoing investigation.

Garett and Garcia on Thursday also expressed their desire to see charges brought against the suspect and said they hoped their situation can inspire changes across the Department of Human Services (DHS) — Child Welfare Services division.

“We are hopeful that criminal charges against Fabian’s killer will be filed promptly and pursued vigorously by the prosecutor’s office,” the statement read.

“We also hope that Fabian’s murder will result in long-overdue changes to the way the State of Hawaii responds to complaints of child abuse against children in the State’s custody. We do not want any other family to have to endure the daily nightmare that we will be living through for the rest of our lives.”

Fabian was pronounced dead July 25, 2017, at North Hawaii Community Hospital in Waimea after police and medics responded to a foster home in Waimea where the child was found not breathing.

Since then, family and friends have organized sign-waving events to show support for the toddler’s mother and keep the public aware of the child’s untimely death.

A pathologist’s report, which the Hawaii Police Department said it received Feb. 22, determined Fabian’s cause of death to be “blunt force trauma to the head,” according to a media release. The manner of death was listed as “undetermined.”

In June, police told West Hawaii Today the case was being reviewed by a second doctor. On Thursday, police said that the forensic pathologist determined the cause of death to be “blunt force trauma to the head” and the manner of death “non-accidental head trauma.”

“Due to these results, a murder investigation was initiated,” police said Thursday in a press release.

The case’s reclassification to a murder investigation and Wednesday’s arrest follows a June Hawaii Supreme Court ruling that overturned a family court ruling that prohibited the parents from speaking about the case.

That August 2017 gag order restricted Garett and Garcia from speaking publicly the names of their two surviving children or publicly releasing reports or other information relating to the case or the parents’ two surviving children. It was ordered after Garcia spoke to the media and Garett wrote a post on Facebook about the case.

The gag order had yet to be lifted Thursday pending a standard 45-day appeal period.

According to the Supreme Court ruling, the family court in January 2016 awarded DHS family supervision of the parents and children based on a petition asserting the parents had substance abuse issues and “hazardous and dangerous” physical living conditions on the parents’ property.

Six months later, the family court awarded DHS foster custody, based on representations from the DHS that the parents were not complying with the family court-ordered service plan. Their three children were eventually placed in a general licensed foster home.

After 3-year-old Fabian’s death, the DHS and the Hawaii Police Department initiated an investigation, and DHS removed the parents’ two surviving children from the home, the ruling states. The children were placed in a different DHS-licensed foster care home.

DHS spokeswoman Keopu Reelitz said Thursday the department intervenes in cases where children’s safety and well-being are at risk or threatened.

“Part of our interventions may include removing a child from their parents’ custody and placing them in foster care with a licensed resource caregiver (formerly referred to as foster parents). Each resource caregiver goes through extensive licensing requirements, which includes orientations, trainings and studies of their ability to safely care for kids,” she said.

Should a caregiver be accused of abuse, neglect or other wrongdoing, the department investigates. At the time of the allegation and throughout the investigation, the department removes any children still in their care and places them with another resource caregiver.

“For now, we want to assure the public that the above outlined policies were followed and the individual identified has not been caring for foster youth since July 2017,” Reelitz said after noting the department generally “cannot provide any confirmation of a family’s involvement in CWS.”


Attempts to reach Alcosiba were unsuccessful on Thursday. She also did not respond to a message sent via social media seeking comment or referral to a representative.

If anyone ever suspects a child is being abused or neglected — whether by a family member or a resource caregiver — Reelitz said DHS urges people to call its 24-hour child abuse and neglect hotline at 832-5300.

  1. PilauAunty August 16, 2018 9:29 am

    This is sad, if she is guilty, she should serve the maximum sentence. Children at that age are precocious, but if you want to be a foster parent, you deal with this. The child was not placed in your care because his parents were stable, so you gotta know this kids come to you with baggage and needs special care, if you can’t handle it, don’t be a foster parent.

  2. Kia August 16, 2018 10:00 am

    Hopefully the truth comes out and let the devil be damned … there are too many true stories where the guilty go free or the innocent serve time behind bars with their lives ruined

  3. Big ideas August 16, 2018 10:30 am

    Dear parents – why was he in foster care to begin with? Drugs? Domestic abuse? Come clean with all the facts.

  4. Castle August 16, 2018 3:56 pm

    Agreed. The foster child was there for a reason. However, the foster parent may not had experience with an unpredictable child of 3 yrs old. Better screening on the State of Hawaii’s part to qualify the family seeking to become foster parents. Shameful a child is left in worse care than the derelict or struggling parents who had given up the duty in the first place.:(

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email hawaiiwarriorworld@staradvertiser.com.